Access, not movement, is what ultimately matters.
This article will be included in the Healthy Living Environment Newsletter. You can subscribe here to stay updated.
Car dependence is not simply the outcome of individual preferences. Commercial interests, public investment and decades of urban planning have helped make driving the default, often at the expense of health, equity and more accessible cities.
For decades, transport debates have treated mobility as an unquestioned good: moving more people, more quickly and over greater distances. But public health needs a different question. Not “how much can people move?”, but “can people reach what they need?”. A focus on access shifts attention towards whether people can reach schools, healthcare, jobs, shops, green space and one another safely and conveniently, without being forced to drive.
Cars are not just a transport choice
This shift matters because cars are more than a consumer product. They sit at the centre of an urban system shaped by vehicle manufacturers, fossil-fuel companies, road builders, parking interests, advertising and other actors that benefit from continued car use. A commercial determinants of health (CDoH) lens asks how these commercial actors, their practices and the wider political and economic system shape health and equity.
The consequences are visible across the city. Car-dominated environments contribute to air and noise pollution, greenhouse-gas emissions, physical inactivity, road danger and community severance, while roads and parking occupy space that could support walking, cycling, public transport, social interaction or nature. What’s more, these harms are not experienced equally. Children, people on lower incomes and those without access to a car can carry substantial costs while receiving fewer of the benefits.
The problem, therefore, is not simply “bad drivers”. Many people drive because towns, services and transport systems leave them with few realistic alternatives. Locating hospitals, schools, employment or new housing where everyday needs are difficult to reach without a car can lock car dependence into the built environment. Asking individuals to make healthier choices while maintaining the conditions that make driving necessary is not enough.
Car dependence is the norm
This is also about culture and expectations. “Motonormativity” describes the tendency to treat driving as universal, natural and difficult to change. Harm may be presented as an inevitable consequence of mobility, while road expansion is framed as the obvious response to congestion. Commercial strategies reinforce this through lobbying, advertising, strategic partnerships, greenwashing and efforts to deny, delay, distort or cast doubt on policies that threaten established markets.
The auto-oil industry makes the commercial dimension particularly clear. Car manufacturers and fossil-fuel companies profit when more vehicles travel further, while other parts of the road economy benefit from infrastructure and development patterns that sustain driving. This does not mean that every car journey is the problem. It means public health must be willing to examine the system and its incentives, rather than placing responsibility primarily on individual drivers.
From mobility to access
An access-based approach offers a constructive alternative. High-access neighbourhoods like the “15 minute city” bring everyday destinations closer together through compact, mixed-use planning, good public transport and safe walking and cycling networks. The objective is not to stop people moving. It is to reduce the amount of forced movement needed to participate in daily life. Instead of measuring success mainly through traffic flow or journey speed, cities can ask whether residents can reach what matters to them.
This framing also changes how we think about physical activity. Rather than relying on education or motivation of individuals, cities can build movement into everyday life. Safe streets, nearby destinations and attractive walking and cycling routes make active travel a practical option for people who may otherwise have little opportunity for physical activity.
…and action
This is where the JA PreventNCD Healthy City Toolbox can help municipalities to prioritise community, health and green space in urban planning. For example, the French Healthy Cities Network, with their partners the cities of La Rochelle, Lyon and Marseille, co-developed a One Health Logic Model tool for evaluating car-free areas around schools. Closing streets to motor traffic around schools does more than encourage families to walk or cycle. It changes the physical conditions, reallocates public space and makes a healthier choice easier and safer. It begins to challenge the assumption that cars must have priority almost everywhere.
If we want healthier cities, we need to move further upstream. That means recognising driving harm, making commercial influence visible and challenging the idea that ever-greater mobility is necessarily progress. The goal should be cities where people do not need to travel further and faster simply to live well. Access, not movement, is what ultimately matters.
Author
Nina Iszatt, senior scientist
Norwegian Institute of Public Health, Norway